The Swiss Family Robinson has been a family favorite since it was first published in 1812. However, it’s been criticized by some for being problematic in its depiction of native people and foreign cultures. In this article, we’re going to explore why this beloved book is considered to be offensive and what can be done about it.
Contents
Lack Of Cultural Sensitivity
The Swiss Family Robinson takes place in a South Pacific island that has never been inhabited by a human civilization. The family is alone on the island and it’s up to them to make a new civilization out of nothing. This idea perpetuates the idea that all cultures are without history or substance, and it overlooks the presence of the native peoples on the island who have their own cultures and traditions.
The book also makes light of foreign cultures, such as the Chinese people who come to visit the island. This is particularly offensive as it treats Chinese culture and history as a joke. There is also a blatant disregard for the animal and plant life that would exist on the island.
Dangerous Colonialist Mentality
The Swiss Family Robinson embodies a dangerous colonialist mentality. It tells a story of a family that is seeking to create a new civilization where none existed before. This perpetuates the idea of white colonialism that was widespread during this time period. Moreover, it suggests that colonizers have a right to come into a foreign land and displace the native people in order to create their own civilization.
It is also important to note that the Swiss family is seen as superior to the native people, as they are able to build a functioning and successful society on the island whereas the native people are seen as primitive and incapable.
What Can Be Done?
Despite the alarming issues present in the Swiss Family Robinson, there are still some good points to be taken away from the story. Reading it can be a constructive experience if the reader is aware of its issues and can use it as an educational experience to explore and discuss topics such as colonialism and cultural sensitivity.
The book can also be used as a jumping off point for conversations about cultural appropriation and the dangers of assuming superiority over other cultures. If we can use the book to start conversations and discussions about these important topics, then it can have a lasting and meaningful impact.
In conclusion, although the Swiss Family Robinson is a beloved classic, it is also rife with problematic themes and ideas that are not sensitive to native cultures or foreign societies. Acknowledging these problems is the first step to understanding how they can be addressed and discussed in a constructive manner.